New Carrollton, MD Homes For Sale

Bargain hunters searching for highly affordable single-family homes for sale in Washington Metro may want to check out a town that was known for having “a lot of turtles” back in early colonial days. That town is known as New Carrollton, Maryland. Although the community is no longer is home to cute shelled slowpokes, it does have intriguing properties with a median list price of about $250,000.

The first landowner in the area was a man named Ninian Beall, who earned his passage to the new colonies as an indentured servant. Beall completed his service in 1677 and was given a parcel of land. At that time, the village was called Terrapin Thicket, due to “a lot of turtles cavorting in the marshy land.” Do turtles indeed cavort? Beall eventually expanded his thicket to 13,000 acres!

The early terrapin days didn’t result in any kind of major land development—but a prominent figure in Maryland horse racing named Edward Mahoney did built a large estate on land once belonging to Beall. After Mahoney’s death in 1957, the land was purchased by a developer named Albert W. Turner who created the city as we now know it, in response to the need for housing for new baby boomers. Homes for sale in New Carrollton, MD sprung up overnight and within a decade, residential development was mostly complete.

Search MLS Listings in New Carrollton

All Listings $100,000 - $200,000 $200,000 - $300,000
$300,000 - $400,000
Price, High to Low
33 Properties Found. Page 1 of 3
Photo of Listing #PG10081862

5900 Lamont Dr

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$374,900

MLS#: PG10081862
3 Bed, 2½ Bath
1825 Sqft, 0.19 Acres
Residential

Photo of Listing #PG10086955

5915 Mentana St

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$344,900

MLS#: PG10086955
4 Bed, 3 Bath
2063 Sqft, 0.19 Acres
Residential

Photo of Listing #PG10101849

8219 Quentin St

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$319,900

MLS#: PG10101849
4 Bed, 2½ Bath
996 Sqft, 0.2 Acres
Residential

5910 89th Ave

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$317,000

MLS#: PG10027230
5 Bed, 2 Bath
950 Sqft, 0.13 Acres
Residential

Photo of Listing #PG9946085

6120 85th Ave

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$315,000

MLS#: PG9946085
4 Bed, 2 Bath
1971 Sqft, 0.16 Acres
Residential

6203 Westbrook Dr

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$314,900

MLS#: PG10098354
4 Bed, 2 Bath
1662 Sqft, 0.32 Acres
Residential

Photo of Listing #PG10074627

6405 Fairborn Ter

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$310,000

MLS#: PG10074627
4 Bed, 2 Bath
1296 Sqft, 0.17 Acres
Residential

Photo of Listing #PG10026237

7316 Sara St Sw

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$305,000

MLS#: PG10026237
6 Bed, 3 Bath
2358 Sqft, 0.17 Acres
Residential

Photo of Listing #PG10077424

8512 Powhatan St

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$300,000

MLS#: PG10077424
3 Bed, 1½ Bath
1250 Sqft, 0.17 Acres
Residential

Photo of Listing #PG10081291

7402 Leahy Rd

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$300,000

MLS#: PG10081291
4 Bed, 2 Bath
1026 Sqft, 0.15 Acres
Residential

Photo of Listing #PG10104125

6509 Fairbanks St

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$300,000

MLS#: PG10104125
4 Bed, 2 Bath
1676 Sqft, 0.17 Acres
Residential

Photo of Listing #PG10097138

8313 Sprague Pl

NEW CARROLLTON, MD
$299,999

MLS#: PG10097138
4 Bed, 2 Bath
1296 Sqft, 0.19 Acres
Residential

More About the New Carrollton, MD Real Estate Market

New Carrollton is home to around 12,000 residents, and while single-family houses are in the majority, about 20 percent of the real estate market is comprised of condos for sale.
The super-low prices have a lot to do with Prince George’s County which experienced a substantial slump in the aftermath of the subprime mortgage crisis. Today, list prices are spiking back up—showing double-digit growth annually since 2012. There is still ground to be made up, however, which means a continued buyers’ market.

Although it is now officially a city, New Carrollton is small in size and has a mostly suburban feel, except for its downtown center which features some interesting modern curvilinear commercial structures. Most of the businesses, including restaurants, shopping and entertainment, are along Annapolis Road, with the local Metro station a few blocks south at Rte. 50.

Condos and townhouses for sale in New Carrollton are primarily located near the community’s southwestern border, with prices starting in the five-figure range. These were mostly built in the early 1960s. Detached single-family homes for sale typically start in the low six figures and don’t often climb past $350,000. You’ll find lots of Ramblers and Split-levels, plus Colonials and Capes. Mo more turtles, but very low real estate prices.

 

The listing content relating to real estate for sale on this web site is courtesy of MRIS. Listing information comes from various brokers who participate in the MRIS IDX.Properties listed with brokerage firms other than District Partners Real Estate are marked with the MRIS Logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers.The properties displayed may not be all the properties available. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.All listing information copyright MRIS 2017.

Listing information last updated on November 24th, 2017 at 4:11am EST.